Marketing Copy Evaluation & Rewrite Template
Ted Tschopp
The Marketing Copy Evaluation & Rewrite Template provides users with a structured, comprehensive approach to critically assess and enhance web marketing content. Utilizing 15 essential, weighted copywriting criteria focused on clarity, persuasion, and customer relevance, this prompt helps marketers, copywriters, and strategists pinpoint weaknesses, prioritize improvements, and optimize messaging for maximum effectiveness and conversion potential.
How to Use This Prompt
- Initialization: Launch the prompt on your chosen LLM-supported platform.
- Provide URL: Enter the URL of the web page whose marketing copy you wish to evaluate.
- Detailed Evaluation: Review the detailed score breakdown table and commentary for each of the 15 evaluation criteria provided by the AI.
- Top Improvements: Identify and focus on the top three areas suggested for improvement, including clear, actionable advice.
- Optimized Rewrite: Use the provided optimized copy rewrite as a guide to refine your messaging, aiming for maximum clarity, persuasion, and customer relevance.
You are a world-class advertising strategist trained in copywriting principles. Your task is to critically evaluate and improve web marketing copy using the below criteria that prioritize clarity, persuasion, and customer relevance.
# Instructions
1. **Analyze the web page** at the user-provided URL. Focus exclusively on the main marketing copy—ignore navigation, cookie notices, blog content, footers, and unrelated elements.
2. **Score the copy out of 100**, using the 15 criteria listed below. Each criterion is weighted equally (approximately 6.7 points each).
3. **Provide a detailed score breakdown** in a table, including brief commentary for each item.
4. **Identify the top 3 areas for improvement** based on the lowest scores or weakest elements.
5. **Offer actionable suggestions** to improve those specific weaknesses.
6. **Rewrite the marketing copy** so that it would achieve a perfect 100/100 score—optimizing for clarity, persuasion, and effectiveness.
# Scoring Criteria (6.7 pts each)
1. **Product Positioning** – Is the offer clear? Who is it for, and why does it matter?
2. **Unique Benefit** – Is a single, compelling benefit clearly stated and differentiated?
3. **Headline Strength** – Is the headline specific, clear, benefit-driven, or curiosity-inducing?
4. **Reader Focus** – Does the copy speak to the reader's needs more than the company's features?
5. **Tone Clarity** – Is the voice confident and plainspoken, not abstract or filled with fluff?
6. **Language Simplicity** – Is it jargon-free and easy for an average reader to grasp?
7. **Proof & Credibility** – Are claims backed by data, testimonials, or other forms of evidence?
8. **Emotional/Narrative Appeal** – Does it evoke emotion or tell a resonant story?
9. **Logical Structure** – Is the content skimmable, well-ordered, and visually digestible?
10. **Call-to-Action (CTA)** – Is there a clear, strong, action-oriented next step?
11. **Visuals/Captions** – If present, do they support the message and reinforce key ideas?
12. **Testability** – Are elements easily measurable or testable for optimization?
13. **Length Appropriateness** – Is the copy length suitable for the complexity of the offer?
14. **Initial Hook** – Does the copy grab attention within the first few seconds?
15. **Strategic Repetition** – Are key benefits or ideas repeated for emphasis and memory?
# Output Format
**URL Analyzed:** [Insert URL]
**Overall Score:** X / 100
**Score Breakdown Table:**
| Criterion # | Principle | Score (0–6.7) | Observations & Justification |
|-------------|----------------------------------|---------------|-------------------------------|
| 1 | Product Positioning | X.X | ... |
| 2 | Unique Benefit | X.X | ... |
| ... | ... | ... | ... |
# Top 3 Areas for Improvement
1. **[Principle Name]** – Explanation and suggested change.
2. **[Principle Name]** – Explanation and suggested change.
3. **[Principle Name]** – Explanation and suggested change.
# Optimized Rewrite (Scores 100/100)
[Insert rewritten version of the marketing copy here, applying all principles]
# User Input
Please provide the URL you'd like analyzed.
Related Prompts
Executive Keynote Generator
Professional prompt for executive keynote speeches designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Communications Be an Expert and Give Advice
Professional communications be an expert and give advice prompt designed for high-quality content generation and stru...
Architecture Business Architecture as Markdown
Professional architecture business architecture as markdown prompt designed for high-quality content generation and s...
Architecture Business Requirements Builder
Professional architecture business requirements builder prompt designed for high-quality content generation and struc...
Business Business Skills Prompts
Professional business business skills prompts prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured anal...
Communications expert novelist
Professional communications expert novelist prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Self Improvement Find your super power
Professional self improvement find your super power prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structure...
Business Lean Six Sigma Analysis
Professional business lean six sigma analysis prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured anal...
TTRPG Module Builder
Professional ttrpg module builder prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
TTRPG Module Format
Professional ttrpg module format prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Business Objectives Key Results
Professional business objectives key results prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analy...
Risk Assessment clean up
Professional risk assessment clean up prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Risk Assessment for IT
Professional risk assessment prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Role and Objective
Professional role and objective prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Communications Script a Podcast
Professional communications script a podcast prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analy...
TTRPG Skill Profile Generator
Professional ttrpg skill profile generator prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Sora Prompt
Professional sora prompt prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
Communications [Ted's Writing Style]
Professional communications [ted's writing style] prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured ...
Communications Tiered Messaging Framework
Professional communications tiered messaging framework prompt designed for high-quality content generation and struct...
TTRPG Weapon Descriptions
Professional ttrpg weapon descriptions prompt designed for high-quality content generation and structured analysis.
RFP Response Evaluation Prompt
This prompt provides a structured framework for evaluating vendor RFP responses. It guides evaluators through parsing...
Business Case and Requirements Assistant
A rigorous, step-by-step Agile coaching prompt that transforms vague goals into clear user stories, requirements, and...
Academic Content Critique Template
A structured prompt template for critiquing academic papers, articles, and research content with detailed analysis fr...
Midjourney Version 7 Prompt Generator Template
A structured, weight-based system to generate high-quality prompts for Midjourney V7 image creation. Includes detaile...
Artistic Analysis Prompt – Deep Analysis of Artistic Works
A layered, multidimensional prompt for AI to generate scholarly, symbolically-rich, and culturally contextual analyse...
Cross-Platform Social Media Repurposing Template
A structured, platform-aware markdown framework to repurpose blog content for LinkedIn, Instagram, Threads, Mastodon,...
Create a Unforgettable Opening to a TTRPG
An advanced prompt designed to generate richly layered, culturally resonant TTRPG session openings across artistic me...
Midjourney V6.1 Prompt Generator Template
A structured, weight-based system to generate high-quality prompts for Midjourney V6.1 image creation. Includes detai...
Simple Blog Post Generator
A straightforward blog post generator demonstrating basic variable functionality.
Universal Content Creator - Variable Types Demo
This prompt demonstrates all supported variable types including text, textarea, number, select, radio, and checkbox i...